The Ford Mustang has been a much desired American classic for decades, and now that it's entered the EV market, it's becoming even more popular. Let’s break down the details between the sporty 2024 Ford Mustang Mach-e, and its chief rival, the 2024 Tesla Model Y.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- The Mach-E’s is futuristic yet plays on classic Mustang nostalgia.
- This Ford EV line is significantly cheaper than Tesla Model Y trim packages.
- The Mach-E’s features are more sophisticated than those in the Model Y.
Trim and Price Comparisons
The Mustang Mach-E has four trim levels than the Model Y, which has only three. In addition to having more options, Ford’s EV trims are less expensive.
- Select: $39,8951
- Premium: $42,8951
- California Route 1: $48,8951
- GT: $52,3951
The Model Y’s MSRPs are:
- Model Y RWD: $45380
- Model Y Long Range: $50,380
- Model Y Performance: 53,880
On top the four options above, even more new variants are headed our way in ‘24 — the GT gets a Bronze Design Series Appearance Package the all-new Rally, an off-road-themed version of GT, will make its grand entrance.
Both the Mach-E and Model Y are eligible for federal tax credits, which will take some strain off your wallet. However, EV tax credits aren’t instantaneous and some new SUV owners who don’t have a large enough tax burden may not get the entire $7,500 credit amount.
A Futuristic Exterior with a Touch of Nostalgia
EVs are the future and the Mustang Mach-E and Model Y speak to a modern look in their designs with their smooth, aerodynamic curves, but the Mustang has something the Model Y will never have — a storied past. Since the days of Steve McQueen’s legendary Bullit chase in his mighty Mustang GT, the Mustang has been the epitome of cool. That cool has been built into Ford’s mighty EV SUV.
The Mach-E continues that legacy — the powerful (albeit redesigned) front grill with prancing pony emblem remains, and the car’s rear taillights pay homage to three-bar Mustang tail lights we’ve all known and loved. The car’s body remains muscular overall, and you never forget you’re driving a classic, even one that’s been revamped for the 21-century.
Ford offers plenty of options to personalize Mach-E — there are double the amount of colors and trim levels to choose from, compared to the Model Y’s offerings. This means you can truly make it your own without breaking the bank on Tesla prices.
The Mach-E’s Spacious Interior
While both EVs are similar in size, the Mach-E is slightly more spacious. While you can see the numbers amounting to just a few inches here and there, that space will make all the difference in the world when you’re under tight squeeze. Here’s the breakdown:
- Mach-E front row: hip space is 55.4 inches and shoulder space is 57.6 inches. Back row shoulder space is 55.9 inches
- Model Y front row: hip space is 53.8 inches and shoulder space is 56.4 inches. Back row shoulder space is 54.0 inches.
Enthusiasts have noted the Mach-E’s warmly designed and comfortable interiors, while the Model Y is typical of a Tesla in its minimalism and stark formality.
Infotainment and Tech
Tesla’s known to be minimalist in terms of its interior and infotainment screen, with very limited upgrade options. Some may appreciate its centrally located touch screen that controls nearly every aspect of the vehicle, while others prefer a lot more flair.
If there’s one thing the Mustang Mach-E excels at it’s flair and we have its storied and legendary models to thank. Ford did not skimp on elegance, offering multiple screens with physical buttons to combine a new and vintage feel while delivering on luxury and convenience.
The Tesla’s lone screen is horizontal while the Mach-E’s is vertical — the smaller screen simply makes reading easier while on the road. It’s all in your eyeline at a mere glance.
The Mach-E features some elements that don't exist in the Model Y, including a 10.2-inch digital gauge cluster and a large 15.5-inch SYNC 4A infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Ready to Get Behind the Wheel?
Now that you know the difference between the 2024 Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y, you can clearly see how the Mach-E reigns supreme. It’s more affordable with more options and it has a cool quotient that can’t be matched. Stop in to experience this fine SUV for yourself. Test drive one today!